Mobile psychiatry: towards improving the care for bipolar disorder
© Prociow et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2012
Received: 30 August 2011
Accepted: 11 April 2012
Published: 29 May 2012
Mental health has long been a neglected problem in global healthcare. The social and economic impacts of conditions affecting the mind are still underestimated. However, in recent years it is becoming more apparent that mental disorders are a growing global concern and there is a necessity of developing novel services and researching effective means of providing interventions to sufferers. Such novel services could include technology-based solutions already used in other healthcare applications but are yet to make their way into standard psychiatric practice.
This manuscript proposes a system where sensors are utilised to devise an “early warning” system for patients with bipolar disorder. The system, containing wearable and environmental sensors, would collect behavioural data independent from the patient’s self-report. To test the feasibility of the concept, a prototype system was devised, which was followed by trials including four healthy volunteers as well as a bipolar patient.
The sensors utilised in the study yielded behavioural data which may be of significant use in detecting early effects of a bipolar episode. Basic processing performed on particular data inputs provided information about activity patterns in areas, which are usually strongly influenced by the course of Bipolar Disorder.
The manuscript discusses the basic usage issues and other barriers which are to be tackled before technology-based approaches to mental care can be successfully rolled out and their true value appraised.
KeywordsMental health Personalized monitoring Bipolar disorder Pervasive monitoring
Mental health has long been a neglected problem in global healthcare. The social and economic impacts of conditions affecting the mind are still underestimated, much as the problems of those who suffer from such illnesses were overlooked and their burden trivialised. However, in recent years it is becoming more apparent that mental disorders are a growing concern not only in the “developed world” but globally as well.
When considered in terms of mortality, mental disorders are not to be found among the main priorities of public health [1, 2]. This is largely due to the fact that the vast majority of neuropsychiatric conditions (even if untreated) do not directly lead to death of the patient. Nevertheless in extreme circumstances these illnesses can increase the risk of mortality (e.g. by suicide) . However, reports, which utilize more complex measures of quality of life to calculate the burden of diseases, rank chronic mental conditions almost as high as respiratory and cardiovascular conditions and higher than all types of cancer and HIV. Moreover, it is projected that by 2030 mental disorders will constitute 15% of the global disease burden with unipolar depression becoming the second highest occurring condition . Considering the rising burden of such conditions, most health organisations and other policy-makers, in their reports, point to the necessity of developing novel services and researching non-costly and effective means of providing interventions to sufferers .
Currently, clinical psychiatry (and psychology) relies greatly on the retrospective self-reporting of patients’ symptoms. Such methods of data collection, whether it is an end-of-day paper diary, simple interview or a structured questionnaire, have one common feature in that the information must be recalled from the patient’s memory . This may lead to misjudgement of the patient’s state as studies show that gathering information retrospectively is subject to multiple systematic distortions and biases (e.g. towards socially acceptable answers) . It is also known that “positive” events are more likely to be remembered than ones with negative association for the respondent. The processing of memories is also connected to the current mood, which introduces even more variability to the recollection process . To rectify the disadvantages of the retrospective method, in recent years, researchers and clinicians have begun to adopt different approaches. The methodologies range from the use of real-time electronic diaries, maintained by the user, to the use of sophisticated technology to extract psycho-physiological information independent of the user’s input . However, the efficiency and effectiveness related to application of these ambulatory assessment methods in general psychiatric practice is yet to be observed. This manuscript presents a technology-based system aimed at facilitating self-care for people with bipolar disorder (BD).
The nature of the BD condition is that patients can experience the extremes of low mood and inactivity (depression phase), which then can swing to hyperactivity and grandiosity in the manic phase. Although, BD is not the most widely spread psychiatric condition, reports show that, among mental illnesses, BD alongside of schizophrenia has the highest “disability rating”. This rating a result of apprising particular conditions in terms of severity and length of disability caused regardless of whether it is social, physical of other kind of disability . Therefore, developing novel means of managing the condition is an important, interesting, yet challenging goal for modern health services which potentially can be tackled using means of personalized, pervasive computing.
In general, it was proven that even diary based “early warning system” against BD can improve effectiveness of interventions 
The occurrence of opposite extremes of behaviour, characterising the condition, is likely to be apparent in physical and social activities possible to monitor via pervasive technology .
Unlike numerous psychiatric conditions patients with bipolar disorder possess in general a high self-awareness and are willing to comply with treatment regime .
Modern developments in sensor technology enable the deployment of ambulatory assessment systems collecting diverse quantitative data, as well as explicit user inputs. Currently there is a wide range of sensing techniques used especially in wellness and health monitoring applications. One group of sensing techniques relates to measuring physical activity and posture. This involves the use of accelerometers, step-counters, gyroscopes etc. Such means are utilised in studies dealing with specific tasks like appraising the progress of Parkinson’s disease , Multiple Sclerosis , detecting falls  or even cough monitoring . Moreover, actigraphy is also used for more general purposes, for example the estimation of energy expenditure and overall activity of the user . These techniques find applications in researching the causes of obesity, stress and other syndromes that could be related to general physical activity .
Depending on the application, ambulatory monitoring systems also incorporate numerous sensors acquiring physiological data, and almost every behavioural disorder has its base in a patient’s physiological mechanisms and biological events are important facets of many cognitive problems . Changes in heart rate, blood pressure, cortisol levels and EEG profiles and other vital signs, are often a definite indicator of numerous mental conditions . Therefore, collecting momentary physiological data may appear to be a valid application of ambulatory technology. However, the main barrier to the wide application of physiological measurements in a real-life ambulatory setting is the cumbersomeness of collecting such data on a day-to-day basis. This renders ambulatory physiological sensors impracticable. A more suitable approach is to monitor patients’ activity via other means. The importance of collecting sensor-based data in addition to traditional self-assessment reports is of particular importance in dealing with psychiatric and psychological conditions. Several studies showed that the objective, quantitative data collected via the use of activity or physiological measurements can differ greatly from the subjective perception of a self-reporting patient . In general, researchers and practitioners agree that while questionnaires are undoubtedly suitable as a method for studying subjective attitudes and representations of an experience, they cannot substitute for actual objective behavioural data coming from everyday observance . However, applying sensor-based ambulatory monitoring into psychiatry is a relatively novel field with very few solutions tested and implemented on a wide scale in clinical practise.
These premises constitute the base for the research presented in this manuscript as well as other investigations into utilizing technology in tackling bipolar disorder. Examples of those include the EU Monarca project , which origins from earlier works on applying monitoring in facilitating the care for BD patients , as well as the PSYCHE project which aims to use smart garments to collect physiological data relevant to mental wellbeing . Both of these implementations aim to identify physiological markers for early signs of an episode. To achieve this, inputs from heart rate to EEG waves would be collected. As such approach may pose an incompliance risk due to discomfort caused by physiological sensors, the methods presented in this manuscript aim to rather collect behavioural data from non-physiological sensors and data collecting techniques.
Bipolar disorder is characterised by occurrences of depressive and manic episodes, each with its own specific outcomes. Often the episodes can directly follow each other. The occurrence of an episode results in major behavioural changes, which are apparent in all areas of patient’s life . The syndromes include psychomotor agitation, loud speech, self-deprivation of sleep in manic episodes and psychomotor retardation, indecisiveness, insomnia in the case of depressive ones.
The established practice of assessing the patient’s wellbeing in bipolar disorder is to interview the patient regularly. The cooperation with the clinician and well-developed self-awareness of the person affected by the condition is key to maintaining the desired mood stability. It is also generally agreed that keeping to a constant life routine is a major factor in dealing with the disorder. The areas of life likely to be affected by an onset of an episode can be monitored by pervasive technology. The main research question for a personalized ambient monitoring system is whether electronically aided observation could assist in recognising early signs or detect known triggers of an episode and prompt an intervention aimed at pre-empting an episode and its consequences.
Bipolar syndromes matched with sensors (M – manic episode, D- depressive, M/D – applies to both)
Altered sleep patterns - insomnia, hypersomnia, self-deprivation of sleep
Possible to monitor with bed sensors as well as light detectors installed in the patient’s home. Effective monitoring of this sleep patterns is of particular importance. Firstly, disturbed sleep can trigger an onset of an episode [25, 26]. Secondly it is an important diagnostic indicator that an episode of either kind is occurring .
Flight of ideas - increased goal oriented activity, euphoria
Monitoring social activity via, e.g., number of visited places (especially in a patient’s free time), number of calls and text messages and their recipients, Monitoring usage of keyboards and household remote controls should also be included, as buttons are likely to be pressed harder and faster.
Psychomotor agitation (or retardation)
Body (e.g. wrist) worn accelerometer will detect restless behaviour and increased activity. Motion detection can also be of use.
Increased (excessive) social activity
Likely to manifest itself in geospatial and temporal patterns (number of visited places). Patients, in their free time, will visit more unusual places and meet new people. These can be monitored via location (e.g., GPS-based) tracking. Identification of crowded places (e.g. clubs) can be achieved through the patient’s mobile device scanning for other devices  or quantifying the noise level of the place where the patient is
Talkativeness – a pressure to talk louder
Monitored by microphones designed to extract the pitch and volume of speech (and not the content).
Concentration problems – indecisiveness
All activities performed on a computer become only related to work duties (e.g. when using of email and web) and they become slow; monitoring keyboard strokes can show decreased speed of typing. Monitoring of household remote controls may indicate lower use.
Lack of interest in social and other activities
Monitoring social activity via, e.g., number of visited places will drop as well as the number of Bluetooth encounters .
Diminished appetite and loss of weight
Regular weight measurements can be automated as well as basic usage of kitchen appliances being monitored.
Sensors constituting the personalised ambient monitoring prototype
Body worn tri-axis accelerometer can facilitate monitoring physical activity, posture and (if worn during sleep) sleep patterns.
Global Positioning System
GPS can be used to obtain precise outdoor location. The information can be used to monitor changes in activity.
Monitoring Bluetooth environment can provide insight into social encounters as well as augment the localisation process
The detector should distinguish between natural and artificial sources of light. Turning the light on and off can be a sign of insomnia, restlessness and other behaviours related to the disorder.
Remote control devices monitor
An Infra-Red detector capable of determining the speed of pressing buttons on a remote control (see Chapter 3).
Simple on/off devices to monitor usage of household items and (if placed on cupboards in food preparation areas) to provide information regarding eating habits.
Passive Infra-Red (PIR) devices to monitor indoor mobility as well as unusual activity.
This can be a pressure mat under the bed or a capacitive presence sensor embedded in quilts
In the first evaluation phase, the system was put to the test in a technical trial involving healthy volunteers in order to establish the usability and identify any fundamental design flaws that may have occurred. The main objective of the trial was to appraise the sensors’ capability of effectively observing the areas of life influenced by the course of BD and detecting slight changes in these areas. Although, in healthy population the observed variations, can be easily attributed to a known cause (e.g. new fitness regime results in higher physical activity), in BD patients can mean a relapse of an episode of either kind. Nevertheless – the changes occur in both cases and testing sensor performance on a group of healthy volunteers was deemed enough for the initial stage.
The second phase was to interview and recruit potential bipolar patients who were willing to test the proposed solutions. The technical trial resulted in five installations. Both trials were granted ethical approval by the UK Research Ethics Committee and NHS Research and Development office.
The environmental sensors were contained in a custom-designed box with several simple peripheral sensors. Motion detectors were standard passive infra-red (PIR) devices as used in anti-burglary systems. Door sensors were a simple on/off switches placed in the most used cupboards within the kitchen area whereas the bed usage sensor was a simple pressure mat placed under the bedsheets. The remote control monitor utilised was an infra-red receiver set to detect any standard remote control transmission used in the vast majority of current entertainment equipment. The sensor did not distinguish between particular commands (e.g. changing channel, increasing volume) but treated each as a “remote control event”.
A total number of four healthy subjects were monitored at the initial stage of the trial. The participants of this trial were recruited from among people well accustomed with mobile technology. The reasoning for such an arrangement was that the trial objectives were mostly technical and could be addressed more efficiently. All participants were interviewed and gave consent according to the established procedures.
The next stage, following the trial with healthy subjects, was to test out the technology in the end user scenario. This meant inviting BD sufferers to test the technology and share their views on all aspects of the proposed system as well as to participate in a trial similar to the one with healthy volunteers. To facilitate this, a recruitment process was started in the Southampton and Stirling areas. It involved approaching patient self-support groups and charities. Following large initial interest during the process, three participants agreed to the initial home visit but only one participant proceeded with the full installation as others withdrew before the second visit. The individuals did not disclose their reasons for not participating and no further contact was made following their decision in agreement with the ethical guidance obtained.
The main objective of the trial was to evaluate the performance of the sensor network as well as to assess their potential for monitoring behavioural patterns in BD patients. Therefore the collected data was pre-analysed in order to determine whether the particular sensor carried information that may be fed further into a processing algorithm capable of recognizing the early signs of bipolar episode. Further sub-sections provide a brief overview of the trial results for wearable and environmental sensors as well as providing insight into general participant compliance to monitoring regimes. The presented results come from the trial involving healthy volunteers. The results of the trial involving the BD patient are covered in a separate section below.
· Identifying the most frequently encountered devices, can provide insight into the number and times of interaction with users of these devices occurred.
· Frequently encountered devices can be often tied to a one particular location. Therefore, such encounters can be useful in enhancing the positioning process where GPS localisation is not available (especially indoors).
· The number of encounters in a single scan can indicate a crowded location like bus or a city centre. This kind of information can also be useful in appraising the participant’s social activity.
Patient trial results
In terms of sensory data, the patient trial produced activity data similar to the sets obtained from the main trial. Since the patient remained euthymic (asymptomatic) throughout the monitoring period, there were no major aberrations from her usual routine. However, the data collected by the wearable node, which depends most on user compliance with a maintenance regime, was far scarcer than from any participant of the technical trial. In one of the intermediate interviews, the patient addressed the issue of not adhering to the routine citing the following reasons:
· Discomfort of carrying extra devices in addition to the mobile phone.
· Forgetfulness regarding charging the sensors, phone or manually starting the monitoring application.
· Lack of familiarity with personal technology in general (not only the PAM system) resulting in underdeveloped user habits.
It can be observed that while the phone was on and monitoring, the remaining elements were either switched off or remained out of Bluetooth range during extended periods. This was typically due to the user carrying the phone but not the rest of the setup.
Problems and limitations
As far as the environmental setup did not cause any discomfort to the users, the wearable sensors, although providing large quantities of behavioural data, exhibited significant periods of inactivity. This relates to the issue of user adherence as all participating users reported a level of discomfort caused by the number of devices that needed to be carried. The fact that the preferred placement of the wearable node should provide it with exposure to the ambient light sources, only added to the problem.
Overall, the main limitation of the work presented in this manuscript is its relatively small scale of the trials. The cohort of participants is too small to derive a detailed behaviour monitoring scheme. Moreover, the high rejection rate among the interviewed patients indicates that the system may present itself as too obtrusive. However, the general notions regarding compliance issues and observations regarding the collected sensory data remain valid and constitute a good base for further investigations in the field.
In this paper we describe the deployment and evaluation of a personalised ambient monitoring prototype that included several sensory devices either worn by the users or placed in their home environment for a purpose of monitoring of onsets of bipolar disorders. Every evaluated element provided potentially useful data about the users’ activity and behavioural patterns. However, the main and most persistent issue discovered throughout the tests was the impracticality of maintaining and “wearing” as many devices on a day to day basis. Such concerns did not apply to environmental sensors as they require minimal maintenance and, aside from the bed usage sensor, caused neither discomfort nor unease. Considering this, a successful wearable monitoring system should not interfere with the user’s routine and habits. Therefore pursuing wearable monitoring via only a mobile phone in connection with a set of simple unobtrusive environmental sensors is a logical choice for further investigations.
Nevertheless, the main conclusion arising from this and similar studies in the field is that despite the technology being developed and sophisticated enough to provide independent insight into patient’s behaviour, psychiatrists and psychologists are yet to adopt such means into their general practise. This contrasts with other fields of medicine where the use of monitoring and diagnostic technology is well established.
Overcoming this barrier requires cooperation between researchers, clinicians and policymakers. Research needs to involve and inform the psychiatric community of positive outcomes of implemented studies. Only then can modern technology-based approaches to mental care can be successfully rolled out and their true value appraised.
The authors would like to thank the EPSRC, UK for their funding of this project (Grant: EP/F003714/1) as well as Sally Brailsford, Christopher James, Evan Maggil, Jesse Blum and James Amor for contributions to conducting the study.
- Murray CJL, Lopez AD: The global burden of disease 2004. 2004, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1-21. 57
- Eaton WW, Martins SS, Nestadt G, Bienvenu OJ, Clarke D, Alexandre P: The burden of mental disorders. Epidemiol Rev. 2008, 30: 1-14. 10.1093/epirev/mxn011.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMed
- Wittchen H-U, Jacobi F: Size and burden of mental disorders in Europe–a critical review and appraisal of 27 studies. Eur Neuropsychopharmacol. 2005, 15: 357-376. 10.1016/j.euroneuro.2005.04.012.View ArticlePubMed
- Ebner-Priemer UW, Trull TJ: Ambulatory assessment: an innovative and promising approach for clinical psychology. Eur Psychol. 2009, 14: 109-119. 10.1027/1016-9040.14.2.109.View Article
- Fahrenberg J, Myrtek M, Pawlik K, Perrez M: Ambulatory assessment - monitoring behavior in daily life settings. Eur J Psychol Assess. 2007, 23: 206-213. 10.1027/1015-57184.108.40.206.View Article
- Tobias BA, Kihlstrom JF: Schacter DL. 1992, Emotion and implicit memory. In Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Christianson S-A, 67-92.
- Morriss R: The early warning symptom intervention for patients with bipolar affective disorder. Adv Psychiatr Treat. 2004, 10: 18-26. 10.1192/apt.10.1.18.View Article
- Basco MR: The bipolar workbook: tools for controlling your mood swings. 2006, Guilford Press, New York
- Andreasen N: Bipolar affective disorder and creativity: Implications and clinical management. Compr Psychiatry. 1988, 29: 207-217. 10.1016/0010-440X(88)90044-2.View ArticlePubMed
- Santosa CM, Strong CM, Nowakowska C, Wang PW, Rennicke CM, Ketter TA: Enhanced creativity in bipolar disorder patients: a controlled study. J Affect Disord. 2007, 100: 31-39. 10.1016/j.jad.2006.10.013.View ArticlePubMed
- Van Emmerik R, Wagenaar R: Dynamics of movement coordination and tremor during gait in Parkinson’s disease. Hum Mov Sci. 1996, 15: 203-235. 10.1016/0167-9457(95)00044-5.View Article
- Ng AV, Kent-Braun JA: Quantitation of lower physical activity in persons with multiple sclerosis. Medicine and science in sports and exercise. 1997, 29: 517-523. 10.1097/00005768-199704000-00014.View ArticlePubMed
- Chen J, Kwong K, Chang D, Luk J, Bajcsy R: Wearable sensors for reliable fall detection. Conference proceedings: … Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society. IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society. Conference. 2005, 3551-3554. 4
- Fukakusa M, Sato T, Furuhata H: [Use of an accelerometer to measure coughing]. Nihon Kokyūki Gakkai zasshi = the journal of the Japanese Respiratory Society. 1998, 36: 343-PubMed
- Mathie MJ, Coster ACF, Lovell NH, Celler BG: Accelerometry: providing an integrated, practical method for long-term, ambulatory monitoring of human movement. Physiol Meas. 2004, 25: R1-R20. 10.1088/0967-3334/25/2/R01.View ArticlePubMed
- Weyandt L: The physiological bases of cognitive and behavioral disorders. 2006, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, New Jersey
- Haynes SN, Yoshioka DT: Clinical assessment applications of ambulatory biosensors. Psychol Assess. 2007, 19: 44-57.View ArticlePubMed
- Bussmann JBJ, Ebner-Priemer UW, Fahrenberg J: Ambulatory activity monitoring. Eur Psychol. 2009, 14: 142-152. 10.1027/1016-9040.14.2.142.View Article
- ,: MONitoring, treAtment and pRediCtion of bipolAr Disorder Episodes. , , , [http://www.monarca-project.eu/]
- Tacconi D, Mayora O, Lukowicz P, Arnrich B, Setz C, Troster G, Haring C: Activity and emotion recognition to support early diagnosis of psychiatric diseases. In 2008 Second International Conference on Pervasive Computing Technologies for Healthcare. 2008, IEEE, , 100-102.View Article
- ,: PSYCHE project. , , , [http://www.psyche-project.org/]
- Ghaemi SN: Mood disorders: a practical guide. 2008, Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Philadelphia
- Wilhelm F, Roth WT: The somatic symptom paradox in DSM-IV anxiety disorders: suggestions for a clinical focus in psychophysiology. Biol Psychol. 2001, 57: 105-140. 10.1016/S0301-0511(01)00091-6.View ArticlePubMed
- American Psychiatric Association: DSM-IV: diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 1994, American Psychiatric Association, Arlington, text:886, 4
- Murray G, Harvey A: Circadian rhythms and sleep in bipolar disorder. Bipolar Disord. 2010, 12: 459-472. 10.1111/j.1399-5618.2010.00843.x.View ArticlePubMed
- Harvey AG: Reviews and overviews sleep and circadian rhythms in bipolar disorder. Am J Psychiatry. 2008, 165: 820-829. 10.1176/appi.ajp.2008.08010098.View ArticlePubMed
- Prociow PA, Crowe JA: Development of mobile psychiatry for bipolar disorder patients. Conference proceedings: Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society. IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society. Conference. 2010, IEEE, , 5484-5487. 1
- Prociow PA, Crowe JA: Towards personalised ambient monitoring of mental health via mobile technologies. Technol Health Care. 2010, 18: 275-284.PubMed
- Prociow P, Crowe JA: Sensors enhancing self-monitoring for people with bipolar disorder. 5th IEEE EMBS UK & Republic of Ireland Postgraduate Conference on Biomedical Engineering and Medical Physics. 2009, IEEE, , 50-52. 1
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.