Skip to main content

Table 4 Summary of mixed model analysis of primary and secondary outcomes (N = 540)

From: Effectiveness of a technology-assisted, family volunteers delivered, brief, multicomponent parents’ skills training intervention for children with developmental disorders in rural Pakistan: a cluster randomized controlled trial

Measurements

Visit

Descriptive statistics

Mixed model analysis

Intervention arm

ETAU arm

Difference in mean (95% CI)

p-value

n

Mean (SD)

n

Mean (SD)

DD-CDAS total disability score

Baseline

270

56.13 (22.56)

270

53.65 (23.08)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

47.65 (26.94)

239

48.72 (26.37)

− 2.63 (− 6.50, 1.24)

0.1820

DD-CDAS—understanding and communication

Baseline

270

59.15 (25.07)

270

58.81 (24.16)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

49.21 (26.97)

239

51.08 (27.87)

− 1.28 (− 6.53, 3.96)

0.6304

DD-CDAS—getting around

Baseline

270

45.17 (42.32)

270

43.56 (40.99)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

37.40 (43.10)

239

39.64 (41.14)

− 2.66 (− 6.75, 1.44)

0.2024

DD-CDAS—self-care

Baseline

270

65.97 (28.24)

 

61.02 (29.28)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

54.58 (33.46)

239

53.09 (32.77)

− 2.66 (− 6.74, 1.43)

0.2020

DD-CDAS—getting along with people

Baseline

270

51.52 (28.85)

270

49.11 (28.12)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

42.85 (30.23)

239

46.07 (30.49)

− 3.60 (− 9.63, 2.42)

0.2404

DD-CDAS—participation in society

Baseline

270

42.74 (21.84)

270

39.27 (23.30)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

37.99 (24.18)

239

38.06 (22.91)

− 1.70 (− 7.82, 4.42)

0.5862

DD-CDAS—life activities

Baseline

270

72.21 (24.76)

270

70.11 (23.99)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

63.90 (31.47)

239

64.40 (30.16)

− 1.83 (− 6.33, 2.67)

0.4245

PedsQL total score

Baseline

270

58.56 (17.37)

270

60.66 (18.69)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

65.56 (23.25)

237

62.17 (22.63)

5.28 (0.44,10.11)

0.0325

PedsQL—parental health related quality of life

Baseline

270

57.09 (20.37)

270

57.90 (22.14)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

63.92 (24.70)

237

60.58 (24.75)

4.43 (− 0.53, 9.39)

0.0797

PedsQL—family functioning

Baseline

270

71.63 (22.64)

270

74.16 (20.26)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

72.68 (24.32)

237

70.27 (25.04)

3.88 (− 1.72, 9.48)

0.1738

PedsQL—physical functioning

Baseline

270

48.61 (23.46)

270

51.74 (25.14)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

61.39 (28.93)

237

57.17 (29.46)

5.73 (− 0.53, 12.00)

0.0728

PedsQL—emotional functioning

Baseline

270

51.91 (26.79)

270

51.97 (27.17)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

61.76 (26.12)

237

56.08 (28.03)

6.23 (0.52, 11.94)

0.0325

PedsQL—social functioning

Baseline

270

65.93 (26.55)

270

65.46 (26.86)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

67.79 (30.62)

237

64.87 (30.18)

3.10 (− 3.43, 9.63)

0.3515

PedsQL—cognitive functioning

Baseline

270

65.37 (27.28)

270

65.13 (27.64)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

66.04 (29.25)

237

65.74 (29.88)

1.24 (− 4.15, 6.63)

0.6509

PedsQ—communication total

Baseline

270

66.44 (24.12)

270

71.45 (23.48)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

70.72 (28.37)

237

66.75 (28.20)

5.85 (− 0.25, 11.95)

0.0602

PedsQL—worry

Baseline

270

38.71 (22.16)

270

43.60 (22.33)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

57.58 (28.66)

237

52.85 (30.09)

6.66 (0.00,13.33)

0.0499

PedsQL—daily activities

Baseline

270

54.81 (31.15)

270

55.80 (30.95)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

57.96 (33.65)

237

56.01 (35.92)

2.95 (− 5.61, 11.52)

0.4984

PedsQL—family relationship

Baseline

270

81.72 (23.57)

270

85.17 (20.92)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

81.52 (24.35)

237

78.84 (26.59)

4.04 (− 1.65, 9.73)

0.1632

SDQ total socio emotional difficulties

Baseline

270

16.50 (5.56)

270

16.50 (6.04)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

16.24 (6.13)

238

16.98 (6.38)

− 0.79 (− 2.24, 0.66)

0.2840

SDQ—emotional symptoms

Baseline

270

3.73 (2.44)

270

3.94 (2.48)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

3.64 (2.41)

238

4.04 (2.53)

− 0.36 (− 0.97, 0.25)

0.2460

SDQ—conduct problems

Baseline

270

3.28 (1.99)

270

3.23 (2.11)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

3.49 (1.86)

238

3.61 (1.86)

− 0.13 (− 0.57, 0.30)

0.5434

SDQ—hyperactivity symptoms

Baseline

270

5.22 (2.29)

270

5.29 (2.25)

  

6 months post-intervention

 

4.77 (2.42)

 

4.90 (2.36)

− 0.12 (− 0.54, 0.31)

0.5965

SDQ—peer problems

Baseline

 

4.27 (2.02)

 

4.04 (2.21)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

4.33 (2.03)

238

4.43 (2.29)

− 0.19 (− 0.69, 0.31)

0.4550

SDQ—pro social

Baseline

270

4.49 (2.94)

270

4.96 (3.26)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

4.86 (3.09)

238

5.20 (3.06)

− 0.12 (− 0.60, 0.37)

0.6395

FES total score

Baseline

270

40.77 (11.07)

270

39.74 (10.16)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

41.41 (9.78)

237

40.89 (9.52)

0.47 (− 1.70, 2.64)

0.6701

FES—service system

Baseline

270

34.60 (12.37)

270

34.24 (10.97)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

39.24 (11.59)

237

38.72 (11.79)

0.55 (− 2.64, 3.75)

0.7344

FES—community involvement

Baseline

270

19.30 (7.48)

270

18.87 (7.08)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

20.28 (8.21)

237

19.48 (7.09)

1.117 (− 2.20, 0.607)

0.26

FES—attitude

Baseline

270

31.70 (9.31)

270

30.86 (8.60)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

32.84 (8.73)

237

32.23 (8.21)

0.53 (− 0.99, 2.05)

0.4936

FES—knowledge

Baseline

270

32.61 (10.24)

270

32.32 (9.15)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

36.14 (10.73)

237

35.45 (9.91)

0.81 (− 1.63, 3.24)

0.5160

FES—behaviours

Baseline

270

30.36 (9.76)

270

29.66 (8.75)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

31.95 (8.78)

237

31.42 (8.45)

0.46 (− 1.72, 2.65)

0.6768

ISE

Baseline

270

2.46 (2.03)

270

2.51 (2.27)

  

6 months post-intervention

221

2.23 (2.05)

237

2.42 (2.23)

− 0.21 (− 0.70, 0.28)

0.3967

  1. ETAU enhanced treatment-as-usual, DD-CDAS Developmental Disorders-Children Disability Assessment Schedule, PedsQL Paediatric Quality of Life Inventor—family impact module, SDQ Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire, FES Family Assessment Schedule, ISE Inventory of Stigmatizing Experiences