Skip to main content

Table 3 Summary statistics and results from mixed-model analysis of primary and secondary outcomes

From: Effect of adding a psychological intervention to routine care of common mental disorders in a specialized mental healthcare facility in Pakistan: a randomized controlled trial

Primary and secondary outcomes

Visit

PM + (N = 96)

TAU (N = 96)

Difference in least squares mean (95% CI)

P-value

N

M (SD)

N

M (SD)

Descriptive statistics n, mean (SD)

 HADS Anxiety

Pre-treatment

95

13.44 (3.67)

96

12.90 (4.02)

  

Post-treatment

73

8.56 (5.00)

73

11.08 (4.90)

− 2.41 (− 4.04 to − 0.77)

0.004

Follow-up

62

8.17 (5.12)

67

10.12 (4.79)

− 1.69 (− 3.41 to 0.02)

0.05

 HADS Depression

Pre-treatment

95

12.18 (3.99)

96

10.80 (3.72)

  

Post-treatment

73

8.16 (4.17)

73

9.92 (4.37)

− 1.85 (− 3.29 to − 0.41)

0.01

Follow-up

62

8.04 (4.89)

67

9.67 (3.94)

− 1.30 (− 2.81 to 0.21)

0.09

 HADS

Pre-treatment

95

25.62 (6.61)

96

23.70 (6.07)

  

Post-treatment

73

16.72 (8.44)

73

21.00 (7.88)

− 4.35 (− 6.99 to − 1.71)

0.002

Follow-up

62

16.23 (8.81)

67

19.79 (7.77)

− 3.10 (− 5.76 to − 0.26)

0.03

 WHODAS

Pre-treatment

96

33.41 (7.17)

96

32.77 (7.77)

  

Post-treatment

74

25.20 (8.97)

74

28.41 (8.19)

− 3.16 (− 6.38 to − 0.85)

0.01

Follow-up

62

22.94 (9.73)

67

27.37 (8.36)

− 4.35 (− 7.24 to − 1.45)

0.004

 PCL

Pre-treatment

96

49.78 (13.99)

96

49.86 (13.66)

  

Post-treatment

61

39.90 (15.89)

63

42.35 (15.73)

− 2.69 (− 8.08 to 2.70)

0.32

Follow-up

61

32.93 (14.21)

64

39.08 (15.75)

− 5.39 (− 10.76 to − 0.02)

0.05

 PHQ

Pre-treatment

96

15.09 (5.17)

96

15.04 (4.99)

  

Post-treatment

53

9.79 (6.71)

54

11.76 (6.51)

− 2.18 (− 4.65 to 0.29)

0.08

Follow-up

61

7.16 (6.23)

63

10.29 (6.79)

− 2.91 (− 5.22 to − 0.60)

0.01

 Days of these difficulties present

Pre-treatment

92

20.9 3 (9.61)

93

20.89 (8.51)

  

Post-treatment

66

13.98 (10.45)

67

18.10 (10.21)

− 3.93 (− 7.44 to − 0.43)

0.03

Follow-up

60

13.88 (11.17)

64

16.67 (9.59)

− 2.80 (− 6.40 to 0.80)

0.13

 Days of total disability

Pre-treatment

91

11.22 (9.78)

92

10.82 (9.47)

  

Post-treatment

65

5.03 (7.15)

67

7.82 (9.03)

− 2.62 (− 5.29 to 0.06)

0.06

Follow-up

60

5.82 (7.34)

64

8.00 (7.82)

− 1.71 (− 4.46 to 1.03)

0.22

 Days of activity reduce

Pre-treatment

90

14.14 (10.26)

92

12.97 (10.19)

  

Post-treatment

65

8.22 (8.40)

67

11.19 (9.58)

− 2.72 (− 5.92 to 0.49)

0.10

Follow-up

60

8.35 (9.57)

64

10.20 (9.69)

− 1.92 (− 5.22 to 1.38))

0.25

 Perceived social support

Pre-treatment

96

51.92 (16.60)

96

52.74 (17.11)

  

Post-treatment

73

55.53 (17.70)

74

51.43 (18.03)

3.85 (− 4.55 to 9.25)

0.16

Follow-up

61

56.61 (17.35)

65

52.57 (14.70)

2.24 (− 3.42 to 7.90)

0.43

 PSYCHLOPS

Pre-treatment

96

15.39 (3.65)

95

14.94 (3.77)

  

Post-treatment

67

9.31 (5.68)

69

11.55 (5.01)

− 2.40 (− 4.19 to − 0.60)

0.009

Follow-up

61

8.98 (5.93)

61

10.62 (4.99)

− 1.63 (− 3.51 to 0.24)

0.09

  1. TAU Treatment as usual, PM + Problem Management Plus, HADS Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scales (subscale score range: 0–21; higher scores indicate elevated anxiety or depression, respectively), WHODAS WHO Disability Adjustment Scale (total score range: 0–48; higher scores indicate more severe impairment), PCL Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist (total score range: 17–85; higher scores indicate more severe PTSD severity), PHQ Patient Health Questionnaire (total score range: 0–27; higher scores indicate more severe depression, PSYCHLOPS Psychological Outcome Profiles (total score range: 0–20; higher scores indicate poorer outcome)
  2. Post-treatment = 7-week after baseline; Follow-up = 20 weeks after baseline