From: Shared care in mental illness: A rapid review to inform implementation
 | COPERATIVE STUDIES PROGRAM 430 Bauer 2009 | Simon 2006 | OPUS Bertelson 2008 | MENTAL HEALTH LINK Byng 2004 | Druss 2001 | Gilmer 2010 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Process of care | Specialty mental health team (.5 fulltime-equivalent (FTE) nurse and a .25 FTE psychiatrist) | Nurse care managers with at least 5 years of clinical psychiatric experience | Assertive Community Treatment, family treatment and social skills training | Facilitation based QI programme designed to improve communication between general practice and community mental health and improve systems of care within general practice (including roles of link worker and psychiatrist) | Integrated primary care and mental health clinic | Full service partnerships and subsidised housing and full fidelity Assertive Community Treatment by team- based services with a focus on rehabilitation and recovery |
Condition | Bipolar disorder and associated co-morbidities including: substance use disorders, anxiety disorders, any current psychiatric co-morbidity and active medical co-morbidity requiring treatment | Bipolar spectrum disorder diagnosed during previous 12 months (bipolar disorder type I or type II, schizoaffective disorder, or cyclothymia). | 1st episode psychosis | Long term mental illness - chronic psychosis, and disabling neuroses | SMI & homeless; co-morbid drug and alcohol abuse. | SMI (schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or major depression) |
Length of follow up | 3 years | 2 years | 2 and 5 years | 1 year | 1 year | 2 years |
Screening | yes | yes | yes | yes | no | unclear |
Additional training for staff | yes | yes | yes - staffed trained to deliver early intervention program | yes - training of research facilitators | no | no |
Treatment algorithm | yes - used to promote identification and treatment by outlining medications to use without sequencing individual agents | yes | no | no | no | unclear |
Formal stepped care | no | yes | no - team assessed as to when patients were ready for a specific treatment modality | no | no | unclear |
Enhanced communication between health providers | no | yes- contact tracking, structured assessment, and standardised feedback reports to providers | unclear | yes - formal communication guidelines around referral, discharge and professional roles and patient management | yes - e-mail, telephone, and face-to-face discussion | unclear |
Care management location | outpatient clinic | behavioural health clinics | primary care office or in patient's home or other places in the community | general practice | primary care clinic and mental health clinic adjoining | community |
Patient education/self management | yes | yes | yes - focus on problem solving and development of skills to cope with illness | no | yes | no |
Case management | yes | yes | yes- team based | yes | yes | yes |
Specialist supervision | yes | yes - weekly | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Care coordination | yes - scheduling appointments and follow-up for missed appointments, and with mental health and medical-surgical providers | yes | yes - across team and social services and other involved institutions | yes | yes - scheduling appointments and follow-up of missed appointments between the two clinics | unclear |
Follow up provided to patient | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Crisis support | yes | yes | yes - crisis plan developed with each patient. Patients given out of hours contact number for response the following day | unclear | unclear | yes - 24/7 |
Standardised outcome measure | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes |